This is What we are

It feels like the current juncture is a real amalgamation of what Everton have been over the last 30 years. There’s been some bright spots and some poor moments and that was on show in the draw at Hull.

It was alright but the handbrake is on for the season due to the off-field situation, some questionable selection decisions and a lack of quality in parts of the field. That’s before you consider the small squad. It feels like it’s been this way since my first game in 1996. The alignment required for a sustained push at achieving anything truly tangible just never comes. And that’s why you trail Hull, come back to lead and then leave with a point.

Sure, Everton are unbeaten in six but context is everything. It’s been a decent start results-wise but there have only been two wins when really, it could have been more. There are positives to take and a couple of negatives but it’s the negatives that hold you back and halt you from really thriving.

Overall, it’s sound, but really you’d like more. That point might look good come May, but it probably should have been three.

O’Brien Should Start

I can’t fathom picking Michael Keane ahead of Jake O’Brien and I’ll be disappointed if the Republic of Ireland international ultimately leaves the club.

He arrived two-and-a-bit seasons ago from Lyon with a good reputation but hasn’t been given the opportunity to grow at centre-back; you know, his natural position.

O’Brien was left out due to a perceived lack of experience which was a rank bad error of judgement by the first manager and then deployed at full-back by David Moyes. Yeah, it shored up the backline somewhat, but also nullified the right side going forward.

Now though, O’Brien isn’t even starting and Michael Keane is being preferred to him. It’s baffling to me. 

When O’Brien has played centre-back, Everton have regularly kept clean sheets and won games of football. The stats show that Keane doesn’t have the same affect.

Looking ahead too - Keane is 34 in January. Why are we managing the situation in a way that could leave us with a need to sign at least two new centre-backs in nine months time should O’Brien wish to move on and Keane is finally released?

I’m pretty confident the clubs in the Premier League who are lauded for making the right decisions more often than not would have long been reaping the rewards of playing Jake O’Brien with Jarrad Branthwaite at centre-back, calling on James Tarkowski when needed. 

It’s the obvious, progressive, forward-thinking choice and so O’Brien still sitting on the bench is seemingly yet another example of Everton just not understanding how to build and grow. Instead the club muddles through the present and misses out on opportunities that are staring them right in the face.

*********

Looking at Sunday in Hull specifically, I don’t like taking James Garner out of midfield but I’d have put him left-back because he is astute and dependable, and I’d have started Hayden Hackney in the middle. 

He’s another player who really looks ready but is slowly going to be phased in for some reason despite nearly 200 professional appearances to his name.

Ainsley Maitland-Niles had a shocker and it made me think Everton are pretty much no further on in their full-back malaise. It makes a difference having a natural right-back there but we knew that when Nathan Patterson was handed an occasional start last season. Ainsley Maitland-Niles isn’t a bad player and he’ll no doubt have good games for us but he was never the answer. Patch-up Job FC amble on and on.

Subjective Offside: Objectively Shite

I couldn’t make any sense of that offside which saw Brennan Johnson’s goal ruled out. I’m sure deep in the laws it’s there somewhere but why have we made the game so needlessly obtuse?

I read Johnson was ‘subjectively offside’ and that’s just daft. Forget interfering with the play and all of the other grey stuff. Keep it really simple, be rid all of the nonsense and get back to basics so we can just enjoy the spectacle. Every game the chat is dominated by this tedious rubbish around convoluted rules.

The fact offside is no longer black and white and actually ‘subjective’ just proves that football in 2026 is objectively shite.

Baffling Barry

Fluffed one, netted one. He’s a perplexing player but the record books will show his name on the scoresheet.

Should he have had two goals on Sunday? Definitely, but he kept going. Time will tell whether Barry’s game will become more refined but while the costly misses have to stop, at least he’s still there to have another go and right the wrong.

The jury of the fanbase is still out but in the meantime, a goal every two Premier League games isn’t bad. Sure, Barry needs to be better in moments, but he’s an improvement on what has been endured in recent seasons.