August 17 will mark 30 years since my first-ever football match.

Everton beat Newcastle 2-0 at Goodison on a bright, sunny day at Goodison Park. The pitch was lush and green and the Gwladys Street vibrant - packed with yellow and black away shirts. Duncan Ferguson, my hero, led the line, stealing Alan Shearer’s thunder who was making his Newcastle debut.

David Unsworth and Gary Speed scored in the victory on the opening day of the 1996/97 season and it was perhaps the last time some people put money on the Toffees to win the title, with Joe Royle’s men seen as dark horses by pundits and hopes high with Andrei Kanchelskis wowing down the wing.

It’s sad to say but three decades on, it was arguably the high point of my support. As it stands, I’ll probably tell my grandkids that I was there the night Goodison shook when we played Fiorentina and then, when they ask the score, I’ll have to inform them we lost on penalties. We actually lost what remains one of my best, core supporting memories. There’ve been a few standout triumphs over Liverpool, United; Arsenal, Chelsea and City too. Couple of Cup runs as well but anything truly noteworthy? Nothing, nada, zilch.

That’s been my time supporting Everton. A couple of mediocre highs and a load of disappointing lows. The times I’ve sighed as I’ve wandered out my row at the full-time whistle must be in the hundreds.

This right now though, this point in 2026 which has been building for an age, this hits different. It’s gone beyond the team not being great and failing. It’s all a bit bizarre. A Groundhog Day haze of nothing but bewilderment.

Now, the number one rule of being a football fan is that you support your team through thick and thin. The thing is with Everton right now though, I don’t feel I’m supporting them through thick or thin. Don’t get me wrong, this is the longest barren run in club history, and I’ve followed them for 99.9% of it, but this feels different to ‘thin’. I don’t know how to sum it up but it’s not the same as watching Everton draw with Coventry to stay up in 1998. It’s different to being a ten-year-old and seeing us lose 3-0 at home to Tranmere. That was thin. More recent years though, it’s been a heavy flow of bemusement and bafflement. Some of the results are still shocking, sure, but it’s almost like Everton have become a parody of themselves. It’s the same season on a loop. The same summers, the same winters; the same decisions that lead to the same outcomes.

The last ten years have been a decade of daftness and this now feels different to us just being a shite-to-average football team. It’s more that we are stuck. Very clearly stuck but almost content to be stuck so long as seventh to 17th is achieved and the worst doesn’t happen.

I don’t understand Everton anymore. I don’t understand how the team can be so dysfunctional, and the entire conversation revolve around the need for a right-back, for example, and that need is just left to fester and no doubt damage us on the pitch.

Honestly, what are you doing? How are you going about this in such nonsensical fashion? What’s the aim here? What’s the long game? Where’s the appetite to get better and push on? What’s this mentality all about? It’s so puzzling.

I’ve seen this film a million times. My assumption, based on 30 years of experience, is the Blues might sign a right-back in a week or two, though more likely days before the window closes. They’ll need to get up to speed and the team may drop a few points in the opening four or five games. That’ll be explained away though as it’s early in the campaign and then, ultimately, Everton won’t finish as high as they could have with a little more urgency to be prepared before the season starts.

Yeah, they’ve done enough to earn their home victory over a United, or a Chelsea, or an Arsenal, or a Liverpool. Hey, they might even beat two of them. Imagine that. But you get the sense they’ll still go out in the second round of the League Cup after choosing to play a second string, they still won’t win away at the Emirates or Stamford Bridge and they’ll still have a dreadful March or April that curtails any hopes of something worthwhile. Then they’ll repeat the process next year and the year after that.

The best Everton team I saw was probably between 2006 and 2009. It was a really good side and that’s simply because every player was competent. Every player could do their job to a high standard. Now though, there are more than a couple who are nowhere near that level and yet we offer them new deals because it’s the easy option. How can you expect to get better? You can’t and Everton don’t expect.

We are reportedly hesitant to do deals for players we desperately need for the sake of a few million that was previously lost in prize money by the self-imposed capitulation of last season. Some talk on social media is that the manager isn’t keen on the players suggested by the recruitment team. That’s fine as it’s he who is responsible and accountable for the side’s performances. But such a recruitment process can’t go on where you wantonly leave gaping holes in your squad and that is where the ownership will soon come under scrutiny as the fanbase grows even warier.

I don’t get it. It goes beyond a lack of ambition or competence, as some fans will perhaps correctly claim. For me, the confusing part is the lack of proactiveness, the urgency, the desire, to get your ducks in a row to actually achieve something beyond just getting by. Putting in the action required so that you can finally stop ‘trying’ and ‘hoping’ to just stand still. I’m sure the club are working really hard behind the scenes but where is the execution, the boldness, the efficiency?

I’m becoming so disengaged. I’m finding that I simply don’t care anymore. And that’s not an ‘I don’t care, I’m throwing a strop because I want Everton to lift the Premier League trophy’, it’s more, ‘I don’t care because I genuinely know what the story of the season will be and it’s utterly tedious and I’m finally, at long last, switched off to it’. Not caring isn’t a choice. It’s just a natural outcome following this feeble football club. I wouldn’t go to the cinema to watch the same film on repeat and yet I watch Everton write this same narrative year after year.

They fail to prepare and are seemingly prepared to fail. That’s how it feels. Happily dissatisfied.

It’s never been the final outcome that’s disappointed me; it’s the sheer lack of intention from the outset. What happens in May starts the previous June. Rinse and repeat.

My fandom has changed in recent times. I’ve realised Goodison was the glue holding it together. I missed around three home games in the last ten years at Goodison. I missed more than that last season.

I’ve realised my personal attachment to the club was in those stands and what it meant to me. The history, the connection, that sense of belonging. That’s what meant I could sit through shite performances still with all of the enthusiasm and passion I had on that first day in August 1996. No matter how poor they were, I was excited to be there again the following Saturday.

I haven’t, though, taken to the new stadium and admit I’ll find it hard to if a different Everton fails to show itself. Each season my engagement in what the team is doing ebbs away that little bit more.

How a new Everton hasn’t forced its way through with so much change is hard to comprehend but its the same Everton I’ve always followed. The club has never ever changed. Not even slightly. From Mike Walker to Carlo Ancelotti, it has remained identical.

I love Everton, I absolutely adore Everton, but I don’t think I have truly liked the club for a good few years now. I have all the time in the world for players like Jarrad Branthwaite, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Jordan Pickford and James Garner. Jake O’Brien, Merlin Rohl… it’s a squad full of good lads it seems. But in terms of football and the decisions made, it really lacks appeal. It’s all so meh. I tend to agree now with outsiders who see us as boring in virtually every way. I’d argue this in the past, now I nod along.

You need there to be something tangible to really believe in. You want your club, your team, to take you on a journey, and they basically leave us at the departure gate every time.

Will this season be different? This is the time of year hope and optimism should be at its peak but I feel so apathetic towards it. I’m not downbeat thinking we will struggle, it’s more that I don’t really have an opinion on where Everton will finish as I’ve checked out a bit.

With the state of the Premier League, the recent Chelsea ruling, VAR and everything else that’s so naff about the modern game, it feels like the matchday I knew and loved no longer exists.

But yeah, Everton, I just don’t get it anymore. I don’t understand. There’s a disconnect and it’s lasting longer than even I expected. This will to muddle through and waste another week, month, year, decade. I’m losing interest and never thought that could be possible.

Thirty years next week since my first game. And I’ll be there on August 22nd, knowing though that there’s probably better ways to spend a weekend. What is happening? I hope it changes one day but I won’t be holding my breath. I can’t be bothered to anymore.


An Everton season ticket holder and football writer, you can subscribe to all of Ell Bretland's work at https://ellbretland.substack.com