Picture this. Rory McIlroy steps onto the green and is just one shot away from winning The Masters. He turns to his caddie before this giant career moment. However, he doesn’t have his putter.

Can you imagine? It would be absolutely absurd and yet this is exactly how Everton are electing to navigate a season at the top level of football.

Persevering without a specialist right-back is like Ronnie O’Sullivan rocking up to the crucible without his cue or Novak Djokovic arriving at Wimbledon with no rackets.

However, those two greats are champions. Everton used to be, but now prefer to be stuck in a loop of ‘trying’, ‘attempting’ and ‘hoping’. Every day is a battle in which the Blues’ hands are tied, apparently.

Except that’s not the case. You see, all of the issues are self-inflicted. Everton spent money this past summer but failed to sign a right-back and it’s bitten them. It’s a theme that’s carried on years now — a failure to replace captain Seamus Coleman which is now continuing under new ownership.

Jake O’Brien, the towering centre-back, has been deployed at full-back for twelve months now. The defender has put in commendable performances but he’s out of position and not a natural for the role.

The farce has ensured the Toffees continue to play in complete dysfunction.

Nathan Patterson, meanwhile, an actual right-back, was dropped a few seasons back after a clean sheet and win at West Ham and has struggled to get back in ever since. I didn’t understand it at the time and still don’t really understand it now.

Anyway, the Scotland international was handed a rare start due to injuries at Nottingham Forest recently and, alongside O’Brien who was at last given the nod at centre-back, helped the Blues earn a win and clean sheet. Everton had found a solution and fielded a balanced side where the play flowed at last.

In true Toffees style though, days later manager David Moyes benched Patterson and shifted O’Brien back. Everton lost and conceded four goals at home to Brentford before struggling to a 1-1 draw with bottom club Wolves. The momentum had been killed and issues arose again.

It was totally unnecessary and easily avoided but this is the Everton way, constantly dealing with problems of their own making.

However, while the struggles are so obvious and needless, it’s the mentality and noises that come out of the club which have you wondering will Everton ever take competing seriously again? Will the Blues ever just get their ducks in a row and do what they need to do? Not to win silverware, as nice as that would be, but to just compete and take on rivals while not being so hamstrung? To go toe-to-toe with other sides without bemoaning a myriad of challenges the team simply choose to endure for months on end? Every week just feels like a patch-up job. It’s not sustainable.

Moyes was asked about signings at a pre-match press conference earlier this week.

“I think it’s probably more unlikely than likely that we add to the squad,” he said. “I wouldn’t say that completely because obviously we’re looking out there to see what there is and we will see if we can get something. But I just wouldn’t want to get everybody’s hopes up.

“We’re looking at some players and we’re looking if we could add to it and if we can we will do, but we’ve been quite careful with it.”

In isolation, there’s nothing wrong with that take but when I listened, I felt my shoulders droop before I exhaled a big mass of despondent air.

Now if Moyes had said it was unlikely a new signing would be made the day before the window slammed shut, I’d get it, but there is just so much wrong with leaning towards expected failure to get anybody in weeks before a transfer deadline. If Patterson isn’t fancied and set to move on, signing a right-back isn’t a want but a need.

I also appreciate there may be a plan in place to keep the powder dry to avoid any PSR blocks in the future but this is a team that needs bolstering or the club will fall further behind still when there is a great opportunity to step forward.

We know January is a difficul period to make signings and that a right-back might not be signed. Moyes is one of the most experienced managers in the world and will know far more than me, a fan, about the lay of the land this month but please David, do get my hopes up. I can’t take this feeling of facing constant uphill battles and struggle much longer.

Fans need something to believe and back. You want your club to take you on a journey.

If the signing doesn’t come, the signing doesn’t come. But football is about confidence, belief and momentum. Tell the fans you’re going to give it your best and they might get to the stadium buoyed rather than flat. Show them the team might actually be heading somewhere rather than standing still.

‘If I say likely, then you might be thinking that that means that we’re on with something,’ is another Moyes line from that recent presser.

I would hope the recruitment team is ‘on’ with something having watched the side struggle for consistency all season because the square peg in the round hole is affecting so much of the pitch.

Where is the urgency to fix a glaring issue? An issue that has been apparent for months, years in fact. In my mind, September through to December should be ample time to know who might be available and who could join the club? I feel it daft to be keeping an eye out in the month of January. Of course situations change, players become available but I just wish Everton and Moyes would at least change the narrative to be a little more hopeful.

You’re not hunting a treasure trove at the bottom of the sea. You’re identifying a specialist right-back. It’s a pool of hundreds. Other clubs just don’t seem to be stuck in this constant state of flux, of being out of answers, constantly, forever.

You want your manager to show a desire to get the job done, not be a carbon copy of that Larry David GIF where he’s so unsure and shows it all over his face.

The messaging is all wrong. Clubs know what we need. A quick look at the squad list tells you that so you don’t need to be coy. Be bold and tell us that everyone behind the scenes is working around the clock to ensure we have the best chance of getting what we need to enjoy a successful campaign.

Listening to the manager, as he shrugs and has the look of a tradesman who has been asked is there any chance he can get more parts at 4.30 on a Friday afternoon, it just leaves you feeling deflated. By the time you get to the ground on matchday, you’re already done because you’ve pretty much been told success isn’t possible anytime soon.

David Moyes has done a great deal of good in the last year but this has certainly been his worst week in the dugout since returning. Changing the team so needlessly completely flipped the feel and so by the time Sunderland came to visit in the FA Cup, the malaise had truly set in.

It was absolutely no surprise to see us limp out and the penalties were a simple metaphor for Everton, getting the build-up all wrong and being spurned. Another chance gone solely due to a lack of fortitude. Shite.

For years, growing up as a teenager, during Moyes’ first spell in charge, his apparent lack of belief and the supposed glass ceiling that pushed down on Everton, used to be excruciating to listen to as a fan who wants to dream. It was for that reason that when he came back in January 2025 and started talking so positively, with verve and drive about being determined to get back into Europe, that it was like listening to a band I’d grown bored of bringing out a fresh new tune. I loved it.

So, what’s changed? Why was Moyes so forthright twelve months ago but now appears sullen? It’s just no good for the feeling and morale around the club.

Excuses aren’t acceptable any longer. Yes, the team is without a number of key players, but being knocked out of both cups (and remember fielding a second string in the League Cup was a choice) before the third week in January has been a symptom of the season as a whole.

For instance, everybody knew AFCON was coming but Moyes has not managed the squad properly to deal with player absences. Tyler Dibling is still only 19 and was signed for £40m. The youngster has either been given minutes at the end of games or starts before being hooked at half-time. He’s not been settled in with sufficient game time so that he was ready for January. Twenty minute cameos in the hole would have given him the freedom and licence to show what he could do. Instead, he’s rusty and being judged.

Then there’s the signing of Jack Grealish. What a signing by the club and a whopping great big positive. But it’s negated by the lack of support the star man receives. Why, when he arrived, did the club not consider Vitalii Mykolenko might not be the man to support Grealish on the left?

The lack of game-time given to Adam Aznou, an overlapping wing-back we did bring in, has been woeful and makes the entire situation all the more galling. The Moroccan was signed in the summer and stuck in the reserves. On Saturday, he was thrown on - another telling factor about how the Cup is undervalued by the club - and made an instant impact, winning the penalty that got Everton back in the game. It proved once again that while the club gets cosy in struggle and strife, there are solutions at times they simply choose to ignore for way too long. It was exactly the case last season when Jake O’Brien wasn’t selected because he supposedly lacked Premier League experience. He was given a chance and swiftly proved that was simply a daft take which has hindered the team for months.

Look, Everton have made great progress under David Moyes this campaign and are four points off fifth. However, ‘off’ is the operative word having drawn and lost two winnable games at home as the team was stifled by bad touchline decisions. It’s so much better than before and yet, points have been needlessly dropped and it will no doubt prove costly come May.

After the win at the City Ground, Moyes had an open road to zoom into and set the season alight with a great chance of six points and a Cup run to be gained from three home games in a week but instead, he pulled in and put the hazards on for absolutely no reason at all.

The excuses simply have to stop and proactive action must be taken while the transfer window is open. Every individual with power at the club now has a decision to make. What type of club do they want Everton to be? The tired old club that perseveres with gaping holes in the squad and thinks being four points off fifth is ample progress? Or an Everton that sees fifth on the horizon and does all it can to grab it with both hands?

People insist ‘This squad will take three transfer windows to fix’. It’s a random figure plucked from thin air which I’ve never really bought into. Aston Villa, for example, went down, came back up, qualified for the Champions League and are in the title contender conversation. Anything is possible with the right personnel in place. Then there’s Sunderland; promoted in the summer, they bought a new squad to compete and have reaped the rewards. It’s been seamless. Everton apparently made some Herculean effort to build a side that’s still not fit for purpose but actually brought in fewer players than the Black Cats who were able to make changes at Hill Dickinson and walk through to the Fourth Round. Go figure.

It’s hard to bring in players but it’s made much easier if you make strong and savvy decisions in the transfer market. Everton though, do not and the hesitation of today just leads to issues for tomorrow.

Honestly, if the club thinks January is difficult to conduct transfer business, failure to bring some bodies in will make the summer a million times harder.

A dysfunctional team with missing parts will cost you millions in prize money, take the shine off new beginnings and continue the narrative that’s held the club back for three decades.

There is still a great chance to achieve something that can push the club forward this season but it depends if the desire is there to go for it rather than ambling through and focusing hard on the hurdles.

I wrote a piece around eight years ago now titled ‘Mediocrity is a disease at Everton’ and still, a cure hasn’t been found. So, so much of this refers to past ownership. However, this is a deep-rooted complex which affects every new player. No matter who comes in as manager or who is appointed at the top behind the scenes, it continues on and on and on.

This was a season of new beginnings and yet I am mired in such familiar Blues misery.

I’ve honestly not felt this frustrated as a Blue in a long while simply because this disastrous week, and it has been disastrous, was so unnecessary, so avoidable and yet, so so Everton.

I’m in no doubt Moyes’ Everton will get back to winning ways and give the fans some pride back. He’s really good at getting a response. However, a season punctuated by such insipid displays witnessed on the banks of the Mersey this week will forever curtail any chance of silverware. I know already any push for Europe, or the top ten, will end in disappointment. A nearly miss once again. You can tell a mile off.

The whole club needs some umph. We simply can’t let a giant opportunity, when the league is so tight, pass us by for the umpteenth time. There has to be a culture change that starts with being proactive, taking action and quitting the excuses. Then, some supporters, like me, might not be so glass half empty.

Right now though, I ask myself more and more ‘What’s the point?’ and each time, I gain more clarity that there is no point. Not while the club is so stuck on this path that leads nowhere.

I long for the day Everton strive to be competitive again.


An Everton season ticket holder and football writer, you can subscribe to all of Ell Bretland's work at https://ellbretland.substack.com