As 2026 dawned, Everton found themselves sitting in 8th spot in the Premier League, heady heights indeed when compared to each season since the days of Carlo Ancelotti when, in the strange Covid year of 2020/21, the Blues started the New Year in the rarified air of 2nd.

In the four years that followed, Everton would kick off the new calendar year in 15th, 18th, 17th and 16th respectively as the club, wracked by the chaos and instability of the later Moshiri years, fought for their top-flight lives under a three different managers.

A year ago, in the wake of a miserable 2-0 home defeat to Nottingham Forest and as Sean Dyche prepared for what would prove to be his final match in charge, there was a danger that either Everton’s luck or the power of its indomitable supporters was running short.

The Toffees were listless under the former Burnley boss, bereft of direction and inspiration, a reality that was driven home at Bournemouth 361 days ago when they failed to register a single shot on target. Within days, Dyche was gone, having informed Everton’s new ownership, The Friedkin Group, that he had taken things as far as he could.

It forced TFG into a decision they would surely have preferred to push out until last summer but they turned, of course, to David Moyes to fill the breach. We’ll never know what other plan of succession the Americans might have had were they deciding from the perspective of a longer-term, more innovative hire but, back in the familiar surroundings of Goodison Park, the wily old Scot had an almost instant impact.

The almost ever-present spectre of relegation was effectively banished by a nine-game unbeaten run in the league between late January and mid-March that began with three consecutive victories over Tottenham, Brighton and Leicester. Moyes was able to coax a vital purple patch out of Beto, who bagged five goals in four matches and his team ended the campaign in the kind of form that, when extrapolated over a season, would have had Everton on the fringes of Europe.

With half of 2025/26 in the books, the Blues are in that same area of the table on the back of consistently inconsistent form, their record peppered with some hugely uplifting victories (including a double over Forest, a notable marker of progress from the previous manager), frustrating draws in winnable fixtures, and a disappointing inability to lay a glove on the current elite; in their meetings with last season’s top six, Everton have lost five, drawn one and scored just one goal.

That last failing has, of course, dogged Moyes throughout his managerial career and, with the exception of the home wins over Fulham and Nottingham Forest, his charges haven’t really put together a full 90-minute performance (the victories at Old Trafford and the City Ground were excellent within their own contexts and in the face of unusual adversity).

The hope is, however, that as the squad-building project continues this summer and beyond, the quality can be added to elevate the team to being a more reliably consistent outfit capable of mounting a genuine challenge for Europe, starting next season.

The foundations are solid, though. TFG, who last month celebrated a year as owners, have ushered in welcome financial stability at a club that has spent years either skirting or breaching Premier League spending limits. 2025 also saw Everton’s emotional departure from their historic home on Goodison Road for a gleaming new edifice on the banks of the Mersey, one that not only places the Blues on Liverpool’s famous waterfront but ensures that record gate receipts have been flowing in since Hill Dickinson Stadium opened her doors for a top-flight fixture for the first time in August.

On the pitch, close to £125m in summer expenditure (which includes the reported £12.5m the club will pay Manchester City to borrow Jack Grealish for the season) did not transform the Toffees overnight into a Europe-ready outfit (it was never likely to given the scale of the restocking task facing the recruitment team at the end of 2024/25) but as some of the younger recruits have started showing their worth during the recent selection crisis that has stripped Moyes’s options to the bare bones, it is clear that the bedrock of a squad capable of challenging on an annual basis in the future is in place.

And yet, thanks to Moyes’s steady hand and a favourably congested league table, Everton find themselves in European contention as 2026 begins at the halfway stage of the 2025/26 campaign. Whether the new year sees the Blues realise their European dream (and whether that squad is ready for what felt at the outset of the season as an unlikely goal) might depend on the injury situation between now and May and how much, if any, business CEO Angus Kinnear and the transfer committee are able to get done during the January transfer window.

Moyes’s strikers have just three league goals between them in 19 games and long-standing attacking limitations in both full-back positions are a continuing hinderance. If some of those issues can be addressed between now and the 2nd of February, Everton’s ceiling for the season might be that bit higher.

Regardless, while patience remains the order of the day the long-term future is bright. After years of stormy waters that threatened to sink the club, 2025 saw the good ship Everton get back on an even keel. To be entering January without the dreaded “R” word dominating our collective thoughts is testament to that!