I'll be honest, ladies and gents, I'm feeling fairly vindicated at the moment. I've long been making the case that ours was a decent enough squad being poorly coached and mismanaged rather than the team of Championship level cloggers that many had painted them as. Thankfully, David Moyes seems to have arrived at the same conclusion and, as a result, we've seen our beloved Blues distance themselves from the relegation scrap over the past few weeks.

Initially, I admit, I advocated for a short-term contract for Moyes, so we could bring in a fresh face in the summer. But, seeing the way the atmosphere and morale around Everton have been transformed, a couple of years of Moyes could be just what's needed to provide a solid and improving football platform and allow the Friedkins the room to focus on restructuring the club, maximising the opportunity that Bramley Moore Dock represents and generally setting Everton up for a more stable, financially-secure and successful future.

And now that all the excitement of the transfer window, the Derby and even the first test event at the Everton Stadium is now over, I thought it could be a good moment to take a detailed look at just what that future will involve in terms of playing staff. We've long heard about the huge number of players who will be out of contract this summer, but just what does that mean for our summer transfer business?

David Moyes has always had an eye for talent. Think back to his first spell at Everton and names like Arteta, Cahill, Pienaar, Baines, Jagielka, Coleman, Lescott and even Stones come quickly to mind. He also did a great job in identifying players who may not have gone on to become club legends but were able to do a solid job in service of the team. Bent. Gibson. Stracqualursi. 

This is all good news because, whether he's doing this solo, with the help of Kevin Thelwell, or with another Director of Football entirely at his side, that eye for talent is going to be needed in absolute bucketloads this summer. 

Players who will be in contract

These are the senior players who, according to TransferMarkt, will be in contract heading into next season, organised according to their positions:

Goalkeeper
Pickford

Defenders
Branthwaite
O’Brien
Tarkowski
Mykolenko
Patterson

Midfielders
Garner
Iroegbunam

Forwards
NcNeil
Ndiaye
Beto
Chermiti

It doesn't take a footballing brain the size of Johan Cruyff to realize that having 12 players (with just one goalkeeper and two midfielders) isn't enough for a whole season. A look at average squad sizes from this season suggests that the best run clubs tend to have a squad of 28-30 players. Let's use 28 as a guide for a squad without European competition to worry about. Where exactly will those other 16 players come from?

Ultimately, there are four sources of additional players:

  1. Youth players moving up

  2. Out of contract players offered a new contract

  3. Loans made permanent

  4. New player acquisition (purchases and loans)

Make the most of what we've got

Most well-blended Premier League squads tend to include 3-4 youth players who can benefit from training with the senior squad full time and being included in some match day squads, as well as gradually gaining minutes through substitute or early cup round appearances.

The obvious candidates for those positions next season would be Harrison Armstrong, who has already played for Everton this season and is now getting experience with Derby County in the Championship; Roman Dixon, who featured a couple of times under Dyche; and Dutch youth international forward Martin Sherif, who Moyes has included in match day squads. With a few other players out on loan or gaining experience by being included in our recent paper-thin squad against Palace, I'd think it's fair to assume at least one more youth player can step up to the senior squad. That gives us 16.

Of our out of contract players, I'd argue that only Begovic (willing to accept his role as second or third string keeper) and Idrissa Gueye should be offered extensions. Although you'd hope we'd be less reliant on a 36-year-old Gueye next season, he's shown himself to have the fitness and energy to at least be an option in midfield. For me, Virginia, Keane, Young, Coleman, Doucouré and DCL have all been fine servants of the club but are either past their best, injury-prone, or not worth new contracts given their age. 

That gives us 18 senior players; so 10 more players are required to make up our 2025/2026 squad as we enter the new stadium. 

Let's start with our current crop of loan players:

  • Mangala: No option to buy was included in his loan from Lyon. At 26 and with Premier League experience, I'd argue that his performances would make a €15m bid worthwhile (assuming he recovers fully from injury).
  • Lindstrøm: There's a €22.5m option to buy in place. At 24, he's the right age profile and seems to have really found his feet under Moyes, but I think he'd have to do more (or Napoli would have to lower their price to close to €10-15m) for this to be a go-er.
  • Harrison: Hard-working but limited. Time to look for better.
  • Broja: Clearly a lot of talent there but too injury-prone to activate the €30m option to buy.
  • Alcaraz: The early signs are very good. Talented but hasn't settled at another club, hard-working but with a touch of class… Charly gives me serious Arteta vibes. At 22, with Premier League experience already, the €15m option to buy could be a no-brainer.

So, let's assume that we turn two of these loans into permanent transfers, giving us 20 players for an outlay of 25 million quid. Where does that leave us?

The squad before new acquisitions

Goalkeepers: 

With Pickford still number 1 and Begovic potentially retained, we're in need of another keeper. As Pickford is just 30, I'd suggest that another experienced safe pair of hands is what's needed here as even an up-and-coming young shot-stopper is unlikely to find their way into the first team in the next four years.

Shopping list: 1 (2nd or 3rd choice) goalkeeper for low/no spend

Defenders: 

Our first choice centre-backs are very strong in Branthwaite, O’Brien and Tarkowski. However, we need at least one more player in that position and, if Moyes continues to prefer this hybrid back 3-4, then you could well argue that we need two more players to fully cover this position on the pitch.

Right back or right wing back is a big unknown. In theory, we have Patterson and Dixon to cover that position, but neither seem to have fully convinced recent managers. And maybe Moyes will continue to play without a traditional right back anyway..? 

Left back is clearer. Moyes has revived Mykolenko's form but we need at least one more player in this position and, in my opinion, this is one area of the pitch where we should be looking to increase the quality of the current first team. 

Shopping list: 1-2 CBs (1 experienced cover; 1 young up-and-coming defender), 1 RB (first choice), 1 LB (first choice)

Midfielders:

Iroegbunam, Armstrong and Alcaraz all seem to be best employed as attacking midfielders, which would leave us well covered should we not renew Doucouré's contract. However, the engine room would look very light with just Garner and Gueye in there, which is why I can see us potentially going back in for Mangala. We also know that Moyes likes a tall, intimidating unit to dominate in there (Fellaini, Souček) so I wouldn't be surprised to see that sort of addition made as well.

Shopping list: 1 CM

Forwards:

Moyes' teams have always used width to deliver balls into the box and we're really lacking for wide midfielders or forwards. McNeil and Ndiaye and the only players who fit this mould to some extent, and maybe Ndiaye is better used elsewhere even. 

We were heavily linked with young Championship players like Sunderland's Tommy Watson and West Brom's Tom Fellows during the January transfer window. I expect we'll bring in at least two players to play in these positions and our interest in those two players could well continue come summer. 

Finally, we have Beto, Chermiti and Sherif to fight for what is in all likelihood going to be one central striker position. Although Beto's improvement under Moyes has been incredible, there are still questions about all of these strikers, as none of them are traditional hold-up and link-up type players in the mould of DCL.

Shopping list: 2 pacey wide players, 1 CF (traditional target man)

The size of the rebuild

When looked at in this way, the enormity of the rebuild really comes into focus. On top of the 25 million spend on making two loans permanent, we need to acquire 10 more players of which, in my opinion, at least 5 should be genuine first-team starters or contenders, with another 5 potentially a mix of younger talent and journeymen – the sort of mix that Moyes blended together successfully during his first stint in the Everton dugout.

The price? Who knows? While two or three of these players may be free transfers and we'll see at least 2 or 3 loan deals, the rest are likely to be pricier. Even unproven young Championship talent costs £15-20m these days. This could easily mean an outlay of £150m this summer just to acquire one of the league's smallest squads. Does that seem reasonable? I guess only the Friedkins truly know.

It suggests to me that at least one big sale could take place. If we lose Branthwaite for 70-80m, for example, we will need to add another CB to that list, but that money could be reinvested into 3-4 canny new signings.

It's important to also stress that this sort of rebuild comes with a lot of positives. First and foremost, we'll be trimming the squad of some of its highest earners while also significantly reducing the age of what is one of the oldest teams in the Premier League. Our average squad age this season is 27.8 years; the average age of the players already under contract next season will be a shade over 24. 

More importantly, Moyes will also have the opportunity to shape the squad in his image and all indications from Moyes, Thelwell and the Friedkins so far have been that we'll be looking at young talent from the Championship, underrated players from less fashionable leagues, plus Moyes has always done very well picking off some of the best talent from teams relegated from the Premier League. The likes of Delap and Dibbling may be too coveted for Everton to attract, but Ipswich, Southampton and Leicester all possess players who would at the very least add a little depth to a puddle-shallow squad.

So what do you think? Do you agree with our needs for this summer? Does the scale of this rebuild terrify or excite you? Maybe I'm missing out on some incredible youth prospects who might help with the rebuild or would you like to see us retain other players like Ashely Young? Who would you be looking at this summer with so many positions in the squad to fill? And how much money do you think Moyes will be given to spend to complete the rebuild?